• IF
    marks John Krasinski’s first rotten rating in years, earning a 56% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
  • Critics are not impressed with Krasinski’s animated family film,
    , as it debuts to low scores.
  • The last time Krasinski had a rotten film was in 2016 with
    The Hollars

Director John Krasinski gets his first rotten rating since 2016 with the debut of his new movie IF on Rotten Tomatoes. Ryan Reynolds stars in A Quiet Place director Krasinksi’s new live-action/animated family film, about a young girl who can see everyone else’s imaginary friends. Just ahead of the IF release date, critics have begun weighing in on Krasinski’s latest directorial effort, which marks a change-of-pace from his previous darker films.

If early critical returns are any indication, reviewers are not high on Krasinski’s turn from horror to family-oriented fantasy, as IF debuts on Rotten Tomatoes with a 56% fresh rating, the lowest score for a Krasinski-directed film since 2016’s The Hollars. It’s still early in the process, of course, and Krasinski’s film could always rebound and sneak over the threshold to be considered fresh.


IF’s Score Continues To Change

Since its debut,
‘s Rotten Tomatoes score has fluctuated even more. At the time of this update, the score has now shifted up to 58%, and it could continue to change in the coming hours and days.

How IF’s Rotten Tomatoes Rating Compares To A Quiet Place And Other Krasinski Films

IF Cast Guide Every Actor & Voice In John Krasinski's Movie
Custom Image by Dhruv Sharma.

Krasinski kicked off his feature film directorial career with 2009’s Brief Interviews With Hideous Men, an adaptation of several David Foster Wallace short stories. Critics were not kind to Krasinski’s first directorial effort, nor were they positive about the follow-up, The Hollars, a comedy in which Krasinski also starred, alongside an ensemble cast including Anna Kendrick, Sharlto Copley, Richard Jenkins and Charlie Day, among others.

John Krasinski’s Films As Director

RT Critics’ Score

RT Audience Score

Brief Interviews With Hideous Men (2009)



The Hollars (2016)



A Quiet Place (2018)



A Quiet Place Part II (2020)



IF (2024)



Critics did not change their tune on Krasinski’s directorial output until he left behind such comedy-dramas and focused on a new genre, horror. The filmmaker indeed had his first critical and box office success with 2018’s A Quiet Place, starring Krasinski himself alongside Emily Blunt. Krasinski then doubled-down with 2020’s A Quiet Place Part II, another critical and box office hit.

The Hollars
is available to watch on Amazon Prime

Critical opinion about IF suggests Krasinski should’ve stuck with horror, as the film is not impressing reviewers. Audiences will get their own chance to weigh in on Krasinski’s pivot to family filmmaking, with the ubiquitous Reynolds in tow, when the movie hits theaters.

Source: Rotten Tomatoes

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *